She always uses tomatoes we’ve canned to make the soup, but I think you could substitute whole, peeled tomatoes if you don’t have canned tomatoes available. This is most definitely a trial and error recipe. I don’t think anyone gets it right the first time (I know I didn’t). Practice makes perfect, though, so if you’re at all interested in this one, keep trying.
This is the original recipe. I think it came from my stepgrandmother. As you can tell, it’s been around for quite awhile!
Tomato Soup with Butter Dumplings
3 jars canned tomatoes (or 2 28-oz cans whole, peeled tomatoes)
salt, to taste
2 tablespoons butter, at room temperature
2 eggs, at room temperature
6 tablespoons flour
1/4 teaspoon salt
Open the jars (or cans) of tomatoes and dump the contents into a large pot. Use an immersion blender to lightly puree the tomatoes. You can also puree the tomatoes in a food processor. Heat the tomatoes over medium-high heat until boiling. Add salt to taste.
Beat the butter until soft. Beat in the eggs one at a time. Stir in the flour and salt. The batter will be lumpy with the butter and flour. Don’t over beat but try to eliminate the flour clumps.
Reduce the heat under the soup so it’s at a very light simmer. Drop spoonfuls of the batter into the simmering soup. Cover and cook for 8 to 10 minutes. Check on the dumplings halfway through cooking and turn them over.
Allow the soup to cool slightly before serving.